Showing posts with label Sketch Shows. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Sketch Shows. Show all posts

Wednesday, 13 January 2016

Review: TRACEY ULLMAN'S SHOW


Tracey Ullman is a British success story most Britons haven't heard of, or at best have long forgotten about. Once part of 1980s shows like A Kick Up the Eighties and Three of a Kind, Ullman famously emigrated to America and found huge success with The Tracey Ullman Show (1987-90) and Tracey Takes On... (1996-99), and is now ranked as the UK's wealthiest female comedian. She definitely lived the American Dream, but now in her late-50s she's returned to her homeland for Tracey Ullman's Show on BBC1.

Sunday, 14 December 2014

Video: SNL's HOBBIT OFFICE


Martin Freeman (The Office, The Hobbit) was the guest emcee of this past weekend's SATURDAY NIGHT LIVE, and the highlight was the sketch I've embedded above. It's beautifully simple: what if the characters of Peter Jackson's Middle-earth saga were employees of an Office-style mockumentary? Freeman amalgamates Bilbo Baggins and Tim Canterbury from his two biggest pop-culture hits, with support from Bobby Moynihan (Gandalf/David Brent), Taran Killam (Gollum/Gareth), Kyle Mooney (Legolas), and Kate McKinnon (Tauriel/Dawn). It's rare for a SNL sketch to make me laugh, but this one managed it.

Friday, 5 September 2014

Video: Norwegian SHERLOCK parodies 'Oklahomo' & 'Mind Phallus'


Norwegian comedians Vidar Magnussen and Bjarte Tjøstheim have made two parodies of the BBC series SHERLOCK, which I'd like to share with you because they're well-made and contain fun moments: "Oklahomo" (above) and "Mind Phallus" (below)...

Tuesday, 3 July 2012

Online Review: DAWSON BROS. FUNTIME

***½ (out of four)



You probably haven't heard of The Dawson Bros. They're a trio of comedy writers (brothers Steve and Andrew Dawson, joined by friend Tim Inman) who have been contributing material to various TV comedies over the years—from That Mitchell & Webb Look and The Peter Serafinowicz Show, to The Friday Night Project and Balls Of Steel. They've also written for the UK strand of website Funny Or Die, which feels like the closest thing to their recent BBC commission Dawson Bros. Funtime.

It's a sketch show pilot, commissioned by BBC Three as part of their "Feed My Funny" web strand, targeting the fertile and increasingly popular sub-culture of the internet and gaming. And it's very funny. In fact, it's so amusing I hope a full series is made for TV broadcast immediately. Funtime is the funniest sketch show I've seen in years, with far more hits than misses (a genuine rarity in the genre), and would be an instant hit if it wasn't tucked away online. I only stumbled upon the show thanks to a link on my Twitter feed (which I duly re-tweeted with enthusiasm), but perhaps that's exactly where the show's core audience of tech-savvy geeks will find it. I hope so.

As I said, the targets of Funtime are almost exclusively focused on the internet and gaming culture. There's an iPad advert opening the tablet up to the equine market, a tour guide offering excursions via the internet, a very funny "Movie Piracy Awards" show (Megaupload was part of the "in memoriam"), a spoof of Sherlock where Holmes is debilitated by the amount of deductions he makes that are visualized as floating text, a version of Twilight with an Egyptian mummy as an unlikely love interest, a parody of motion-sensor games consoles, a very funny sketch about internet pornography going social and embarrassing its users, and a bravura music video about stalking girls through Facebook (that owes something to the work of Saturday Night Live's Andy Samberg). You can take a look at some highlights for yourself:



If you're giggling already, you need to watch this show on the BBC's iPlayer immediately. It's definitely precise in its target (under-34s who love technology and marinade themselves in pop-culture), but that's no bad thing. It knows its audience, which is great, and if you're part of the demographic it's aiming for you should enjoy this. The sketches are brilliantly paced, the performances from the cast of unknowns were great (take a bow Chris Kendall, Cariad Lloyd, Jenny Bede, and Mike Wozniak), the laughs come thick and fast, and even its most obvious jokes/ideas add something unexpected to make them palatable.

My only concern is that a full series wouldn't quite go the distance, because this pilot scratches a lot of immediate itches. I have to wonder if a third, fourth and fifth episode would be as hilarious, once the Dawson Bros have offloaded most of their best ideas and have to start finding targets that are a little more unexpected. But as pilots designed to grab people's attentions go, Funtime is an unquestionable success. A half-hour of almost non-stop laughter, if you're attuned to its geeky sensibility, topped off with a voiceover from Peter Serafinowicz himself—whose own comedy style this show definitely compliments.

I demand more, BBC Three...

Watch the whole pilot here, if you're in the UK.

Wednesday, 9 May 2012

Review: CARDINAL BURNS (E4)


Cardinal Burns is the perfect sketch show for youth-skewing E4, as comedians Seb Cardinal and Dustin Demri-Burns transfer their stage expertise to television, relatively fresh from sell-out shows at the Edinburgh Festival and London's Soho Theatre. It's always exciting to see fresh faces on our screens, with no baggage and preconceptions clouding what they do. It's simply a case of: are these two men and what they write funny? Thankfully the answer was a definite yes, with Cardinal Burns turning in a strong first episode that actually got progressively better after the ad break.

Five laugh-out-loud sketches and one potential classic in a little under thirty-minutes? You can't argue with that hit-rate, especially as everything else kept a solidly amusing standard.

It was noticeable how many of the duo's targets were creative types, too: actors, artists, filmmakers, reality stars, street poets, etc. It gave the show a hip quality as they punctured the pretensions of such people the youth of today look up to, or aspire to become. The most triumphant sketch being a hilarious audition where a jobbing actor was put through unreasonable and humiliating demands in an audition, culminating in him miming a threesome with two invisible giant hawks. Quite a broad joke, but tempered with brilliant physicality, observations, and remarks—such as the perfect moment with the director's confusion the actor couldn't comply with his demand to defy gravity. A brilliant moment, but there were others snapping at its heels...

My second favourite sketch was probably The Real Banksy, which hysterically poked fun at the world-famous street artist's mysterious persona. Here he was revealed to be a conceited dimwit making dumb political statements after trips to Homebase to buy his paints, constantly wearing a false nose-moustache-glasses disguise. It was one of those idea you can't believe someone hasn't done until now, which are often the best.

Also raising some laughs were the vomiting cops (a modern answer to Monty Python's Mr Creosote sketch, where two hard-faced detectives couldn't stop themselves puking over everyone and everything at a gruesome murder scene), Jean-Pierre the fly (where a French fly-wrangler's trained insect was offhandedly killed during the making of a movie), and bizarre parody of MTV's The Hills called Young Dreams (where three young fashions interns flatshare, including one unintentionally rude Japanese girl who points out another girl's enormous mole).

I wasn't quite so enamoured with the other sketches, such as Office Flirt (where a nerdy man's status as the harmless office flirt was spoiled by the arrival of hunky newcomer), but nothing was outright terrible. Or anywhere close to poor, really. This was a strong half-hour debut for Cardinal and Burns, which should help win them a big audience through word-of-mouth for E4. Well, provided they haven't put all their best stuff in the first episode, of course. If subsequent weeks keep this level of quality, are they destined to nab the British Comedy Award from Horrible Histories next year?

Aside

  • You can see more from The Real Banksy on his very funny Tumblr. A clip of a forthcoming sketch is also embedded below. And you can follow the duo themselves on Twitter.
written by Seb Cardinal & Dustin Demri-Burns / directed by Ben Taylor / 8 May 2012 / E4

Saturday, 5 May 2012

VIP, 1.2 - episode two


Impressions shows are amongst the toughest of TV genres to review, because there's little to say beyond listing which impressions worked, which didn't, and which sketches made you laugh, and which didn't. And even that's all very subjective. But after last week's promising start, I was relieved to see that episode 2 of Very Important People (VIP) was possibly better in some respects. It felt like there was more crammed into the 30-minutes, and there was plenty of new impressions to sit alongside the recurring ones. If nothing else, VIP is achieving a regular half-dozen laughs from me, per episode, purely through Morgana Robinson's version of Amy Childs gurning every other sentence.

Morgana's Russell Brand was also brilliantly observed in terms of dialogue and body-language, although it's impossible for her to imitate the deepness of a man's voice. She's naturally better with the women, although I was disappointed her attempt at Dragons' Den's Hilary Devey was lacking. Although the harsh makeup and the lunacy of the sketch (Hilary flashing her crotch, Basic Instinct-style, which was revealed to be a jabbering man's face), somehow overcame the weakness of the impression.) It sounds like I'm being harsher on Morgana this week, but she's still a genuinely absorbing screen presence. Her facial expressions alone are TV gold, and she can transform herself with aplomb; going from bug-eyed gormless (breathy Natalie Cassidy) to drop-dead gorgeous (a twee'er version of Sophie Dahl, getting high on mushrooms).

The emphasis this week was more on Morgana's cohort Terry Mynott, whose impression of David Attenborough and Terry "Wa gwan" has really grown on me already. It's just a shame this episode's main recurring sketch was its weakest: Barack Obama as the Jon Stewart-esque chat show host of "Live From The White House". I'm really not sure what this was trying to say about the current US President, beyond the fact he's slick and "showbiz", but is that really true? The best impressions are those that crystallise something we're all thinking about deep down, or have recognised in famous people. It's the little things brought to the surface through another's interpretation. I wish VIP was more interested in getting under celebrity skin in such a way.

As it stands, so far it's been a procession of amusing ideas and sketches (Bear Grylls "surviving" in an urban environment after being thrown out by his wife, for example). Some more relevant than others, as this episode involved a sketch where Adrian Chiles and Christine Bleakley zoomed around in a motorised sofa, literally chasing scarce Daybreak viewers. A fun idea, but both presenters have long since left Daybreak, and the show itself was axed in recent weeks. It just goes to show how much impressions shows thrive on topicality, as you were just left scratching your head over an outdated joke.

Still, VIP already feels more worthy of your time than anything we've seen in the genre lately, but that's a question of taste. You get more impressions from the likes of Jon Culshaw on BBC1, but his targets are family-friendly in an early-evening timeslot. I much prefer a show like VIP that's pushing boundaries post-watershed, even if the standard of impressions isn't as robust and the jokes sometimes puerile. Although, as I keep saying, Morgana Robinson's an absolute marvel you can't take your eyes off.

Fridays – Channel 4, 9.30PM

Saturday, 28 April 2012

Review: VERY IMPORTANT PEOPLE


The Morgana Show had a mixed reception last year (myself included), but few denied the colossal talent of its eponymous star Morgana Robinson. Very Important People (VIP) reunites Morgana with fellow impressionist Terry Mynott from that series, to form a satirical double-act Channel 4 hope will kick this sub-genre of comedy out of the comfortable groove it's become trapped in (mostly thanks to family-friendly BBC commissions like The Impressions Show). A return to the '80s heyday of Spitting Image is due, perhaps. But did VIP make a good impression?

For a first episode, I've seen far worse. The impressions were mostly very good, occasionally exceptional, with only a few outright duds. It's unusual to have a comedy where the female impressionist is given more to do than her male associate, but such is the talent of Morgana Robinson that you'd be foolish to shove her into the background. It's not even a problem there are typically more men than women in the public eye to make fun of, as Morgana made a fairly convincing man on three occasions: as outrageous Scottish comedian Frankie Boyle; garrulous Russell Brand; and, most convincingly in terms of body language, "hard-man" actor Danny Dyer (filming "Britain's Hardest Commutes")

I'd hate for this review to dissolve into a love-fest, but I really do find Morgana a remarkable performer. Her pouting, breathy Amy Childs was hilarious (mainly for making us realize the Essex girl has a habit of pulling stupid faces at the end of sentences); her impression of ex-EastEnders actress Natalie Cassidy was indistinguishable from the real person; her Fearne Cotton (a holdover from The Morgana Show) reminded us why it was deservedly celebrated (she's more fun than the actual Fearne, too); and I can even forgive Morgana's ropier moments because there's always a spark of humour somewhere (a so-so take on The Voice's Jessie J enlivened by her tongue-waggling "new reaction face").

Things didn't go quite so well for Terry Mynott, who was slightly overshadowed because he didn't deliver an impression you haven't seen done better elsewhere—with the possible exception of a funny Sir David Attenborough, commenting on Frankie Boyle's work ethic. Mynott's version of Brian Cox (the physicist not the actor) came a distant second to Jon Culshaw's high watermark, while nobody does a better Terry Wogan than Peter Serafinowicz (although I liked the offbeat idea of Terry "wa gwan" hosting a radio show from a Jamaican beach hut). I hope Mynott gets to show what he can really do in future episodes, because the YouTube video that got him noticed highlights some brilliant impressions I'd like to see on VIP.


Like all impressions shows, VIP had to satisfy two key audience demands: hearing good impressions where you don't need any exposition to tell who the celebrity is, and generally funny and plentiful sketch ideas. It was here the show was more miss than hit, unfortunately. For every genuinely funny/clever idea (Adele being incomprehensible to people unless she sings a heartrending ballad) there were about three sketches that floated by. It would also have been better if VIP had shown its fangs more, because the best sketches were the most savage (like claiming Frankie Boyle sleeps well after hearing about a child's death, because it will result in 10-minutes of comedy material).

VIP's wise to assault the modern craze for trashy celebrities and dumb reality TV shows, but it needs to really go for the jugular with its targets. It was nevertheless interesting to note that one of VIP's writers is Matt Morgan, best-friend and collaborator of Russell Brand--who didn't escape this show's attention. So at least that's a promising sign nobody's off-limits, even if there's a direct connection to someone on the staff.

I hope Morgana Robinson, Terry Mynott, and the writers refuse to let VIP slip into that unfortunate position where celebrities openly say they love being the subject of its barbs. We could do with an impressions show that the rich and famous genuinely fear appearing on, to some extent. Or have times changed too much since Spitting Image turned Kenneth Baker into a literal slug in the '80s? To be talked about disparagingly still means people know who you are, after all. Isn't that all that matters to VIP's in the 21st-century?

Overall, I'll be keeping an eye on VIP. Morgana's a very talented person (beautiful enough to convince as the likes of Cheryl Cole, yet able to contort her face to play both "ugly" and "men" with apparent ease). It's just a pity the format doesn't really allow for Morgana to create original characters (e.g. her brilliantly observed young boy Gilbert), but I guess the tepid response to The Morgana Show has put that aspect of her talent on hold for now.

The common problem with impressions shows is that they tend to burn brightly but quickly. Everything's fresh and you're hearing new imitations every few minutes for a few episodes, and then show get steadily less remarkable due to necessary repetition. This is where good writing and performances are essential, because I'd happily watch "Amy Childs" or "Fearne Cotton" time and again if they're given something funny, creative, and insightful to say and do every week.

What did you make of VIP?

27 April 2012 / Channel 4

Saturday, 12 November 2011

Review: THE FAST SHOW online - episode 1


The Fast Show was the best and worst thing to happen to British comedy in the mid-'90s. It revolutionized sketch shows thanks to its blistering pace, visual style, and imaginative range of well-drawn characters, while transforming co-creator Paul Whitehouse from Harry Enfield's "stooge" to full-blown comedy legend in his own right. But it was also responsible for crystallizing the idea that catchphrases and repetition in sketch shows were easy shortcuts to hilarity and popularity—as so many shows that followed were likewise keen to arm themselves with built-in reiteration (most notably Little Britain).

This BBC show ran for three series (including some specials) from 1994 to 2000, and in that time became big enough to attract a guest appearance from mega-fan Johnny Depp. And now, over a decade later, it's back. Have the BBC chosen to revive it like Shooting Stars? Well, no. An Australian beer company have. Fosters had unprecedented online success in bringing back two comedy giants this year (the sublime Alan Partridge series Mid Morning Matters; the ghastly Vic n' Bob series Afternoon Delights), so it makes sense that they'd chase down The Fast Show next. Its format and fizzing pace is perfect for the internet age, where watching comedy on YouTube has helped erode attention spans to the bone. Or to put it another way: we've embraced Family Guy over The Simpsons.

So how successful is The Fast Show's online return? The first seven-minute installment "went live" a few days ago (embedded below), and fulfilled its primary mission to please fans of the show. The core troupe have been reunited: co-creators Whitehouse and Charlie Higson, joined by regulars Simon Day, Arabella Weir and John Thomson, with the added bonus of Caroline Aherne (an original alum who left after series 1), but sadly without Mark Williams. Most have aged gracefully, and it helps that many Fast Show characters were already significantly older than the actors playing them, so there's no notable difference between rambling Rowley Birkin QC circa 2000 and 2011.

Perhaps wisely, there are no new characters in this project. I remember on television it always took about three episodes for new characters to really "connect", and that's too long for an online show chopped into seven-minute chunks. Consequently, most of your favourites are returning, opening in this episode with fan-favourites Ted and Ralph (in the weakest sketch of the bunch), the hilariously crazy "Chanel 9"  news crew and their bizarre "Spanish" language, unintelligible drunken raconteur Rowley Birkin, and tough-guy actor John Actor as Monkfish in a timely Downton Abbey/Upstairs, Downstairs spoof.

Just over five minutes isn't long enough to settle into a show's groove, and I missed the studio laughter the TV version always used very well, but other than that... Foster's Fast Show is essentially a continuation of the original show, with a slightly wrinkled cast and less budget. The writing doesn't appear to have slipped too badly in the ten-year gap, although I still think this show belongs as a pleasant memory from the past. It's fun to see familiar characters after a long absence, but where it was once irritating that The Fast Show relied so heavily on catchphrases, it's now relying heavily on catchphrases from a previous century. "Scorchio!" and "Does my mum look big in this?" were mimicked all over playgrounds when Oasis and Blur were fighting for chart supremacy, but that now seems like a very long time ago watching this.

Another problem is that Alan Partridge's own online series was beautifully written and, by virtue of the medium, had to focus on its strengths: intricate dialogue and Steve Coogan's nuanced performance. In contrast, The Fast Show is just doing what it was doing all those years ago, only with less money and cultural significance. As a fan of the TV series I'll be sticking with this, but don't expect a brilliant reinvention for a new medium.

Aside

  • If this series proves as successful as Alan Partridge's Mid Morning Matters was earlier this year, will a proper TV return be on the cards? Interestingly, Partridge's online run is apparently being bought by Sky for a re-edited broadcast on TV, when you'd expect the BBC to have snapped it. It just goes to show how fast the TV landscape is changing now, as old shows find new leases of life online or on digital channels (see also Red Dwarf's return next year, following three successful specials on Dave in 2009.) Even in America there's a feeling that online entertainment's beginning to find its niche--with UK acquisitions like Misfits and The Only Way Is Essex doing brilliantly on Hulu, and companies like Netflix financing their own shows (starting with a US remake of the UK's House Of Cards miniseries).
Updates every Thursday @1PM / http://fosters.co.uk

Wednesday, 14 July 2010

'THAT MITCHELL & WEBB LOOK' 4.1


I used to follow this sketch show every week, breaking it down into sketches, but I'm not going to bother now. This opener for the fourth series was underwhelming, and it irritated me that David Mitchell and Robert Webb have chosen to stick with the Get Me Hennimore and Remain Indoors sketches, which both ran out of steam halfway through series 3. It also opened with a Fry & Laurie-esque moment with the duo standing in front of the live studio audience as "themselves", which for some reason just doesn't seem to work for Mitchell & Webb.

There were a few highlights (like a pedant who kept killing employees for their bad grammar during a pitch meeting, or Caesar being taught how to refer to himself in the third person, a mumbling actor who can't read the line "I don't know what you want anymore" with the required energy, and a scientist for Laboratoire Garnierre being chastised for using his skills to cure Alzheimer's), but even allowing for the "hit-and-miss" nature of sketch shows, this episode felt more weak than usual. And if it's true that all sketch shows broadcast their best half-hour first, to ensure viewers come back for a few more weeks at least, then I'm worried about series 4 as a whole. Still, as usual, Mitchell & Webb's work never patronizes its audience and doesn't rely on recycling jokes and catchphrases, so for that I'm grateful and will still be tuning in.


13 JULY 2010: BBC2, 9PM

Sunday, 1 November 2009

Box-Eyed: Did Jon Culshaw make a good impression?



For the second week running, there's just the one review in my Box-Eyed column over at Newslite.tv, this one taking a look at Jon Culshaw and Debra Stephenson's new impressions show, er, The Impressions Show.

"For many people, impressionists are only above ventriloquists on the ladder of entertainment. Both are "party trick"-style skills that audiences find diverting, but the actual content of their material can leave a lot to be desired. Consequently, both have their peaks and troughs in widespread popularity, but there's generally an appetite for lighthearted impressions-based sketch shows – something less politically-motived than Rory Bremner, and more along the lines of Alistair McGowan's Big Impression or Dead Ringers." Continue reading...

Sunday, 19 July 2009

THAT MITCHELL & WEBB LOOK 3.6


The final episode of this third series was quite average, really. Last episodes of sketch shows tend to give the running gags an amusing twist, but only the "Get Me Hennimore" sketch provided a tweak to its formula, while the excellent "Remain Indoors" quiz unwisely vanished back in episode 4. A real missed opportunity. Sadly, even this week's best sketches tended to drag their ideas out too long, or else had unfunny punchlines, giving the whole episode a disappointing feel.

Great: A mediavel scientist who keeps inventing useless products too advanced for their time, like a wireless computer mouse and car windscreen wiper; cosily British TV promotion (although the punchline that this was being watched in a post-apocalyptic wasteland was terrible); Mitchell is persuaded to be given a massage by Webb, who proceeds to act sexually when he rubs his friend's shoulders; brother's execution (funny idea that two brothers would have nothing to say to each other on the eve of one of them dying, but stretched out far too long).

Good: Drunken hotel; David Mitchell addresses the live studio audience over budget cuts (they should do more of this stuff because the "live" feel was fun and reminded me of A Bit Of Fry & Laurie, but this "sketch" was let down by a dud punchline); garrulous idiot TV exec demanding something identical to Numberwang; and the Marmit glove.

Bad: Text-for-sex (spoof of phone chatlines that are already beyond spoof); the Old Testament God sees how far he can push Abraham into doing terrible things; "Get Me Hennimore", where the hapless office worker imagines various likely catastrophes as his boss talks, manages to avoid them all, only for a nuclear bomb to inexplicably go off outside (a poor end to a sketch series of mixed success); Wagner's Ring Cycle on mobile phone text; and text-a-blog (yes, this episode's recurring mobile phone gags were terrible.)

Sunday, 12 July 2009

THAT MITCHELL & WEBB LOOK 3.5


The penultimate episode of Mitchell and Webb's third series is something of an oddity, because there's not really a lot to love or hate. Most of the sketches fell somewhere in the middle and even the successes weren't as sharp as usual, but it still passed the half-hour well enough.

Great: Subtext messages (amusing idea that mobile phone texts now follow-up messages with the true subtext behind them); a world where all students get A's in their exams; Get Me Hennimore (confusion with the letters 'n' and 'm' this week, in a cleverly written piece.)

Good: Two nutricionists scamming patients with New Age twaddle; a King who has a baron he keeps favouring, to his other subject's frustration; Bussman & Christmas buddy cops, where the latter is a detective permanently stuck in the festive spirit; "My Shags As A Whore" (fun critique of shows like Secret Diary Of A Call Girl, where prostitution is presented as something fun); two guru's on a plinth (a bit daft, but it made me smile); and the anti-CSO copper returns from episode 1.

Bad: Two world-famous cellists intending to turn their terraced house into an interntional airport because they're tired of carrying their cellists around; "can I borrow your pen?"; and an overlong sci-fi sketch where everyone uses the word "Vektron".

Friday, 3 July 2009

THAT MITCHELL & WEBB LOOK 3.4

A definite return to form after last week's disappointment, thankfully. 80% was good, 10% great, 10% bad, and that's not to be sniffed at. As always, it's just nice to get mostly new content in a sketch show every week, and Remain Indoors is a weekly dose of genius...

Great: A recurring sketch with a terminally ill patient having his dying wishes carried out by a compassionate friend, only to grow bored of them after all the massive effort (snowboarding with penguins, reenacting Die Hard, sleeping with his friend's wife); the Remain Indoors quizshow (still excellent, loved the conveyor belt prizes); and low fat "Cressps".

Good: A chef pastiche of Gordon Ramsey, poking fun at the flaws in his Kitchen Nightmares series; homeopathic A&E (kind of obvious, but nicely done); a Pompeii soothsayer suggesting they start recycling in the face of certain death; a Butler discovering his master has believed him to be his gay lover for the past 40 years; and a silly discussion about weeing in the shower.

Bad: Linford's Sprinting Nightmares (M&W don't have much success with quick gags); a couple mistakenly believe their friends have invited them round for a swingers party (didn't work); Get Me Hennimore (the weakest mix-up yet, involving a giant bee and a jar of jam); and misunderstood texts.


2 July 2009
BBC2, 9.30pm

Friday, 26 June 2009

THAT MITCHELL & WEBB LOOK 3.3


The worst episode so far, sadly. Mid-series episodes don't tend to be the strongest in sketch shows, and episode 3 was definitely lacking the big laughs and intelligent ideas M&W are capable of. There were worryingly few highlights to sustain the half-hour, for me. Comedy is subjective, but does anyone agree this was rather dull? To summarize:

Great: The new sports drink Glucozade Port (alcoholic isotonic); and a Bond spoof where Agent Suave visits a casino of parlour games, to try and defeat a villain who's his equal at guessing the weight of cakes.

Good: A dinner-guest makes a fuss of being a carnivore in a reversal of the "vegetarian" issue; Mr. Darcy busts disco move in a Pride & Prejudice parody where toffs are dancing The Conga; a man commits suicide behind a weatherman by leaping off a roof during an outside broadcast; Sir Digby Chicken Caesar returns and Ginger is sober following a car accident (a fun development of characters I'm bored of); a Best Man speech where he's embarrassingly honest about the bride's attractiveness (dragged a bit); and an Antarctic expedition where the starving explorers try not to eat food designed for special occasions (advent calendars, harvest festival hampers, Christmas puddings, etc.)

Bad: The Queen becomes a "special guest" star, but proves to be terrible on camera; another "Get Me Hennimore" sketch poking fun at the mix-up comedy of '70s sitcoms (we get the joke now, move on...); and another Captain Todger superhero press conference (really bad).

Sunday, 21 June 2009

Box-Eyed: Are Thursdays Still Funny?


In this week's edition of Box-Eyed over at Newslite.tv, I take a look at BBC2's new Thursday night comedy line-up, with capsule reviews of fantasy spoof Kröd Mändoon & The Flaming Sword Of Fire, sketch show That Mitchell & Webb Look and horror-comedy Psychoville.

Friday, 19 June 2009

THAT MITCHELL & WEBB LOOK 3.2


Hit-and-miss. Just kidding! Well, it wasn't as good as last week's opener, but there weren't too many sketches that didn't make me giggle or smile, if only a few that had a genuinely brilliant idea behind them. It's a shame that a few of M&W's better ideas are stretched beyond their natural end-point, though. Which leads me to...

Great: A really funny sketch with Webb playing a clichéd German mad scientist from the '40s whose "Death Ray" is revealed to be an antiquated bardcode reader (let down by the sketch continuing past the "tinned peaches" punchline, growing unfunnier every second); a sketch with an imaginary Gary Rhodes helping a gay man during a first date; round 2 of the post-apocalyptic Remain Indoors quiz; and the return of the snooker commentators in a documentary showing how they both won the 1975 championship.

Good: Obvious advert slogans (not punchy, just rambling and needlessly specific); women-focused adverts to "sort themselves out" in comparison to men-focused adverts to just shave and get drunk; a little poke at the common complaint that sketch shows are "hit-and-miss"; a ventriloquist thief (loved the cops capturing the dummy and interrogating it for five hours); "Get Me Hennimore", a pastiche of '70s sitcoms and their obvious set-ups (much funnier than the golf one last week); Polite Taxi Driver (simple idea, but Webb was funny); and a sketch with Webb complaining that Mitchell's started performing parts he should play (using split-screen doubles.)

Bad: Posh Jaws (brief, not funny); and Captain Todger, an uncouth superhero at a press conference that the police would prefer didn't speak to the press.

Friday, 12 June 2009

THAT MITCHELL & WEBB LOOK 3.1

When David Mitchell and Robert Webb transferred their Radio 4 sketch show to BBC2, That Mitchell & Webb Look became an award-winning success. Together with their infamous roles in Peep Show, this "double act" were suddenly red-hot talent. Mitchell became a regular of the comedy panel show circuit, while Webb... well, he won Let's Dance For Comic Relief by reenacting Flashdance in tight lycra and a wig. A disparity the pair themselves poke fun at in the third series of TM&WL, this one aiming to scrub away the bad taste of that sorely disappointing second series...

With the proviso that first episodes of sketch shows are intentionally the strongest to lure audiences in, I found this opener solidly written and very funny for the most part. There were only a few obvious duds, with most of the sketches hitting their marks and a handful eliciting big laughs.

The great: Mitchell as Poirot, deducing the culprit of a crime by waiting for one of the suspects to use "the evil voice"; a spoof of The Apprentice where the candidates are all super-talented business brains, so the Sir Alan figure is forced to fire "the fat one"; a terrible quiz show being broadcast after some unspecified post-apocalyptic "Event" with constant warnings that viewers don't go outside, featuring a contestant referred to as Unknown Male 282; and a spy drama consisting entirely of clichés because the writers have no experience of that profession.

The good: Webb as grinning Euro inventor Jan Hankl, who has patented the action of slapping your thighs to help find a missing item; a brain surgeon mingling at a party, making full use of the phrase "it's not exactly brain surgery, is it?"; Mitchell and Webb's action figures (Mitchell's has a huge vocabulary, Webb's comes with an extra T-shirt); Queen Victoria being lambasted by an aide for daring to comment that a tree species being given to England smells like cum; and Webb inventing an alternative to doorbells that involves shooting dogs through windows with a note attached.

The bad: A policeman sneering at having to patrol with a lowly Community Support Officer; a '70s sitcom-style golf sketch that just didn't make much sense to me; a Newsnight-style show on "dumbing down" being filmed on a cooking show set (wisely lasting only a few seconds); and Santa Claus' scoundrel brother Russ coming to stay, bemoaning how his Winterfest X festival hasn't taken off like Christmas, then making a move on Santa's wife Joan.

Altogether, this was a promising start. I think the key to M&W's success is that, besides being talented performers, they avoid the trap of merely regurgitating catchphrases (a nasty hangover for UK comedy thanks to Harry Enfield and The Fast Show), and the wit and intelligence of David Mitchell is evident in the writing. Even the sketches that don't amuse are at least nicely-written and unfunny. The best kind of unfunny, obviously.

If That Mitchell & Webb Look has one failing it's that their comedy tends to revolve around poking fun at media tropes, history and literature. This is possibly because you "write what you know" and the pair are in the TV biz and a university upbringing has instilled a love of British history and books -- which is fine, but episodes feel a bit constricted by their aim at times. It's not exactly holding a mirror up to contemporary life, which is what the greatest sketch shows do.

They can also become very preachy at times. While their Apprentice sketch was cynical and funny, it was spoiled when M&W (as TV producers) started to talk condescendingly to the audience about exactly why The Apprentice formula is so manufactured and its viewers idiots to enjoy it. A reality show that a huge portion of M&W's audience probably really like. Way to alienate, guys! At least we've moved on from Big Brother being the whipping boy, but now the decent reality TV is getting it in the neck?

Still, considering their audience are going to be young adults raised on TV, it's perhaps not so unwise for them to focus their efforts on parodying the goggle-box like this. I guess I'm just bored by the amount of TV spoofs around these days. Whenever M&W do shift focus to everyday concerns, it's never their finest work (see the policeman sketch this week.) But I know they CAN go beyond easy showbiz targets, as David Mitchell's excellent vodcasts tackle humdrum topics with wit and insight. Search for them on iTunes.

Overall, I'm going to resist proclaiming this a return to form without seeing more, but there was nothing here to make me think ill of the new series. They even appear to have axed Sir Digby Chicken Caesar and Numberwang before those fan-favourites were stomped into the ground -- thank God. Famous last words..?

Anyway, it's great to see a sketch show that appears to have been crafted with care and attention, despite its inevitable flaws and a few concerns. Compare this episode to a whole run of any sketch show BBC Three throw at the screen... and there's no competition.


11 June 2009
BBC2, 10pm

Sunday, 15 March 2009

TV Week #37: Horne & Corden, The Big Red Nose Climb & Comic Relief Does The Apprentice

My thirty-seventh TV Week over at Newslite.tv features a reprise of my reviews for The Big Red Nose Climb and Comic Relief Does The Apprentice, but also features a brand new review for BBC3 sketch show Horne & Corden. Enjoy!

The critics have savaged HORNE & CORDEN, but it's not as awful as other BBC3 efforts with a similar format (The Wall, Blunder.) I guess everyone just expects more from this ubiquitous pair, who have yet to equal their Gavin & Stacy breakthrough. The problem with this sketch show is brutally simple: H&C are talented performers, but weak writers. I think it's safe to assume that Ruth Jones, the co-writer of Gavin & Stacey, is the real brains behind the award-winning series -- which, let's be honest, appeals to audiences more for its feelgood factor than an abundance of belly-laughs. Continue reading...

Sunday, 1 March 2009

TV Week #36: Moving Wallpaper, Al Murray's Multiple Personality Disorder & Celebrity Juice


My thirty-sixth TV Week is an ITV-only affair, with a look at mockumentary Moving Wallpaper, sketch show Al Murray's Multiple Personality Disorder, and comedy panel show Celebrity Juice.

"While definitely entertaining, [MOVING WALLPAPER] just seems to lack the kick, insight and inventiveness that similar shows (like 30 Rock) achieve much easier. I'm also not sure a traditional ITV audience will get the joke (or be that interested in zombies), while the audience tuning in for Kelly Brook and horror-tinged comedy will probably find Moving Wallpaper rather toothless. Still, for an ITV comedy, this is already their best attempt in years -- and I'm hoping we'll get to see the Renaissance pilot as the last episode." Continue reading...

Saturday, 3 January 2009

Christmas Catch-up

The Christmas edition of Radio Times has run out of pages, so I guess that's the official end of Christmas and New Year television. Here are some mini-reviews of shows I watched, but won't get around to reviewing properly...

I was disappointed with Wallace & Gromit: A Matter Of Loaf And Death, weren't you? Great animation, some fun moments, imaginative action scenes, a few good in-jokes (especially Ghost and Aliens), but it all felt too insular, predictable and repetitive to me. Wallace gets another love-interest, there's another killer on the loose (human this time), Wallace just gets dopier and needs rescuing again. The only notable change was having the obligatory dog turn out not to be the villain's accomplice. After the Curse Of The Were-Rabbit feature-length movie (shown earlier that afternoon to highlight this point), Loaf & Death felt like a step backwards for Nick Park. Why not create some new characters, instead of sticking to the safe bet of W&G? Oh well, 15 million people watched, which will hopefully bankroll a BBC-funded movie before Peter Sallis snuffs it.

The Peter Serafinowicz Show Christmas Special was surprisingly good fun, given the fact I disliked the original sketch show when it aired earlier last year. The quality control was definitely higher (although the next-day midnight extended repeat reinserted a lot of grot) and I was glad it didn't just put a festive spin on old sketches. A good 85% of it was new stuff -- and I'm still giggling at the intimidating estate agent ("did I arks you?") and the insane job interview ("you passed the test!") Let's hope a second series builds on this upswing in quality.

Contrarily, the QI Christmas Special was... well, just a regular episode of average quality. I can understand they've run out of seasonal trivia, but this "fire and freezing"-based special wasn't worthy of the Christmas Special tag in the slightest. A big disappointment on that count, but I thought Dom Joly showed promise as a new panellist and Rob Brydon was very funny. I loved his recurring gag of explaining obvious things as if they were secret gems of knowledge.

The Strictly Come Dancing Christmas Special was background sparkle for me on Christmas Day. The second "voting scandal" for Strictly in as many weeks overshadowed it, too. This time, four couples tied with 39 points after the judges scores were added up, so the studio vote was entirely redundant, meaning Len Goodman had to put the top four into order of merit before voting could continue. But it was all nicely edited to look like this was the accepted way of handling the situation. As for the show itself: well, Kelly Brook was robbed.

Mock The Week Christmas Special? Nope. Mock The Week repeats all edited together, I think you'll find. Bah, humbug!

I caught bits of Alan Carr's Christmas Ding Dong. I hated the first series of this gameshow (with Carr mistreating "civilian" people in front of his chummy celebrity pals), so it was no surprise the second series quickly changed the format to a celeb-versus-celeb competition. This panto-themed special seemed quite fun, but the only thing I can remember is Paul Daniels planting a smacker on Alan Carr.

The Have I Got News For You? Christmas Special was okay, even though it was just another normal episode, masquerading as a festive special because of fancy dress. I just wish they'd give Alexander Armstrong the hosting job full-time and ditch the annoying guest-host idea entirely.

The 25th anniversary Blackadder Rides Again documentary was fifteen minutes of worthwhile information and footage, separating clips that sometimes didn't even last to the punchlines. G.O.L.D's Blackadder documentary a few months ago covered most of the bases here, so this was a bit tiresome for me. For fans, there wasn't much to get terribly excited about -- unless you liked to be reminded how dour and humourless Rowan Atkinson is in real life (he admits it himself), wanted to see a clip from the original pilot episode (is the whole thing available as a DVD extra?), and that terrible last shot of Blackadder Goes Forth (before a bit of slo-mo and piano music transform it into one of British comedy's greatest moments.)

ITV really didn't have a good Christmas, did they? Did they have anything worth watching? Oh yes, Affinity. Shame I missed that. Harry Hill's TV Burp Review Of The Year seemed like a safe bet, but I think I can feel a backlash coming on for Mr. Hill. After winning two BAFTAs this year, I'm kind of expecting more from this show now. And, truth be told, it all looks a bit too half-baked, formulaic and childish to me now. Maybe it always was? The clever, eagle-eyed observations are being swamped by desk-set slapstick. There are still some laughs, but this special wasn't much fun. I hope Harry manages to recharge for 2009, but ITV are flogging their only comedy hit to death with this extended run. A breezy seven episodes every three months is enough for me.

Charlotte Church's Nutcracking Christmas Special was on in the background, so I caught bits and pieces. For me, Charlotte's still a damn terrible presenter who should stick to singing. And the full-on celebration of Wales over the past five years is beginning to annoy me (with Ruth Jones and Rhydian flying the Welsh flag here.) Want proof that Charlotte Church should just disappear, or get back in the recording studio? Check out her unfunny secret camera stunt with Jeremy Edwards (feeding him ideas as he auditioned panto actresses) A terrible moment in Charlotte's hand, rescued completely by James Corden grabbing her mic and ad-libbing funnier ideas than anything Charlotte's feeble mind could improvise.

While hardly in the festive spirit, Top Gear's Vietnam Special was great, blokey fun. Clarkson, Hammond and May pootling up Vietnam in clapped-out scooters, aiming to complete the journey in eight days. Torrential rain, unexpected natural beauty (a good advert for the Vietnam Tourist board, funnily enough), war memorials, silly games, a daft driving license challenge, and more staged comedy interludes (the transporting of cumbersome gifts was particularly strained.) As usual, you're never sure what genuinely happened, and what was orchestrated by the production team weeks in advance... but when it's all this entertaining, I really don't care enough to complain. Catch it on Dave in 2009, every two hours.

I also saw BBC Four's Crooked House three-part chiller from writer-actor Mark Gatiss, and thought it was very good. In fact, I liked it enough that full review will hopefully be along next week.

What about you? Did the Christmas TV schedules impress you this year? Too many repeats? Were the specials not really special enough? Did anyone care about the return of oldies like The Royle Family, Rab C. Nesbitt and Jonathan Creek?